Goths Don’t Kill People. Guns Do.

In the wake of the unspeakable tragedy that took place in Newtown, Connecticut on Dec 14, it’s understandable that people would try to understand how something like this could happen and how another human being could do such a horrendous thing to defenceless young children and adults. Sadly, it seems that rather than really trying to get to the root of the problem, the media has yet again decided to scapegoat a small minority of young people. This is a selection of headlines from Sunday’s newspapers:

“He was a nerd, genius, Goth”: Profile of gun killer Adam Lanza – Daily Mirror

School gunman Adam Lanza ‘a loner’ and ‘one of the goths’ – The Sun

Goth loner was ‘ticking time bomb’ – Daily Mail

Adam Lanza Described As ‘One Of The Goths’ – CBS

And the newspapers go on:

Last night, a troubling portrait began to emerge of the ‘Goth’ loner, who dressed all in black and was obsessed with video games. Other students remember him walking through school dressed in black, carrying a black briefcase. Catherine Urso, whose son knew the killer, said: ‘He just said he was very remote, one of the Goths.’ (Daily Mail) Family and friends remember Adam Lanza as many things — intelligent, nerdy, goth, remote, thin. (Fox News)

I could go on but you get the picture. For some reason, the media seems to think it is okay to indulge in this kind of senseless scaremongering that can achieve little other than embitter and isolate more teenagers. When we use the labels “Goth” or “nerd” or any other similar epithet as shorthand to describe a severely disturbed individual like Adam Lanza, we do nothing more than marginalise and alienate more young people. Being a “Goth” is not akin to having a mental illness. It is a lifestyle choice and says little about the young person other than the type of music they like to listen to and the way they like to dress. And, of course, that they want to belong to a social group. But then, what teenager doesn’t want to belong to some social group?

Ever since the Columbine school shooting, it seems the knee jerk reaction is to label any such individuals as “Goths” (for “Goths” see “freaks”) as if this alone explains their behaviour and motives. The first thing to remember is that “Goths” are not a single social entity. There are many sub-groups within the “Goth” culture, all with different beliefs, styles and tastes. But, more importantly, the main thing to remember is that these young people are exactly that: people. Human beings with thoughts, fears, hopes, insecurities. No different from the quarterback or the Prom Queen, if we’re going to indulge in stereotypes.

And let’s also remember that fears and insecurities are writ large in our teenage years. Do we really want to add to that by labelling these teenagers as would-be killers or possible “time-bombs”? Because make no mistake, that is what will happen. If the media continues to label those who dress differently or listen to loud music as “freaks” and “outsiders”, that is exactly what the teenagers concerned will feel that they are. And they will react accordingly. And if – God forbid – we have a repeat of Friday’s scenario, the media will wring its hands and wonder once again where it all went wrong.

Advertisements

3 comments on “Goths Don’t Kill People. Guns Do.

  1. Sandy says:

    Well said! Thank you for this. To label the killer as anything other than mentally ill not only closes the door on a mental health availability/affordability discussion, but further isolates anyone who is different.

  2. I was a Goth twenty years ago in middle school. I still love punk and goth music, but I would never think of doing what Adam Lanza has done.

  3. amyeyrie says:

    So true. Labels are a way of diminishing people and dehumanizing them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s